SlabHawkSlabHawk
Jay Cutler card image

Jay Cutler Rookie Cards

Price Guide · Last 30 Days
$45
Last PSA 10 Sale
$1,320
Total Sales
$22
Average Sales
59
Total Volume
NaN (0%)

Jay Cutler Market Summary

Who Is Jay Cutler?

Jay Cutler arrived as a 2006 rookie quarterback. SlabHawk tracks 36 of his graded rookie cards across 50 sets.

Jay Cutler Card Price Overview

Jay Cutler rookie cards are trading at an average of $22, with 59 sales totaling $1,320 in the last 30 days. The most recent PSA 10 sale closed at $45. Prices have held steady over the last 30 days.

Card Sets & Variations

SlabHawk tracks 36 popular Jay Cutler rookie cards across 50 different sets — one of the more widely represented players in the hobby, including Bowman Chrome, Topps Chrome, and Score. Prices range from $0.40 to $255 across all grades, so there are entry points at every budget level.

Market Outlook

Jay Cutler sees solid trading activity with 59 sales in the past month, indicating sustained collector interest. Keep an eye on upcoming card releases and season performance for signals on where prices head next.

Jay Cutler Parallels & Variations

Collectors chasing Jay Cutler parallels can track 15 distinct variations beyond the base card, including Autograph, Ruby, Preview Ticket-Autograph, Refractor, Gridiron Gear-Platinum, Autograph-Gold. Within Bowman Chrome, tracked parallels include Refractor, Blue Refractor, Autograph, Gold Refractor.

Where Jay Cutler Cards Trade

Across grading companies, Jay Cutler sees liquidity in BGS, Raw and PSA. No SGC activity is tracked yet.

Jay Cutler Grade Breakdown

Sales activity across grades over the last 30 days.

GradeTotal Sales (30d)Avg Change (30d)
Raw450%
PSA1080%
BGS9.560%
BGS920%
Get Full Access Today
  • No setup, or hidden fees
  • Cancel Anytime
  • Add unlimited cards to your collection
  • See entire history of cards
  • Get Started Now
Hero Showing the main dashboard and a video

Jay Cutler Rookie Cards

Jay Cutler Score #350 Base
Jay Cutler

2006 Score #350 Base Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
3 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Ultimate Collection #203 Autograph
Jay Cutler

2006 Ultimate Collection #203 Autograph Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
3 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Topps #365 Base
Jay Cutler

2006 Topps #365 Base Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
2 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Bowman Chrome #222 Base
Jay Cutler

2006 Bowman Chrome #222 Base Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
1 sales · PSA10 · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Topps Heritage #125 Base
Jay Cutler

2006 Topps Heritage #125 Base Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
2 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Leaf Rookies & Stars Longevity #201 Ruby
Jay Cutler

2006 Leaf Rookies & Stars Longevity #201 Ruby Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
2 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Playoff Contenders #27 Preview Ticket-Autograph
Jay Cutler

2006 Playoff Contenders #27 Preview Ticket-Autograph Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
2 sales · BGS9 · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Playoff Prestige #198 Base
Jay Cutler

2006 Playoff Prestige #198 Base Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
2 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Topps Total #464 Base
Jay Cutler

2006 Topps Total #464 Base Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
2 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Press Pass Legends Legends Autographs # Base
Jay Cutler

2006 Press Pass Legends Legends Autographs # Base Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
2 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Topps Draft Picks & Prospects #173 Autograph
Jay Cutler

2006 Topps Draft Picks & Prospects #173 Autograph Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
2 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Bowman Chrome #222 Refractor
Jay Cutler

2006 Bowman Chrome #222 Refractor Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
2 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Topps Chrome #229 Refractor
Jay Cutler

2006 Topps Chrome #229 Refractor Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
1 sales · PSA10 · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Topps EA Sports Madden 07 #11 Base
Jay Cutler

2006 Topps EA Sports Madden 07 #11 Base Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
1 sales · PSA10 · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Donruss Gridiron Gear #157 Gridiron Gear-Platinum
Jay Cutler

2006 Donruss Gridiron Gear #157 Gridiron Gear-Platinum Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
2 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Fleer #146 Base
Jay Cutler

2006 Fleer #146 Base Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
1 sales · BGS9.5 · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Topps Chrome NFL 8306 #NFL8 Base
Jay Cutler

2006 Topps Chrome NFL 8306 #NFL8 Base Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
2 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler SA-GE Aspire #36 Base
Jay Cutler

2006 SA-GE Aspire #36 Base Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
1 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Spx #159 Autograph-Gold
Jay Cutler

2006 Spx #159 Autograph-Gold Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
1 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Topps Heritage Chrome #THC64 Base
Jay Cutler

2006 Topps Heritage Chrome #THC64 Base Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
1 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Playoff Prestige Draft Picks #DP4 Rights Autograph
Jay Cutler

2006 Playoff Prestige Draft Picks #DP4 Rights Autograph Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
1 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Topps Turkey Red #190 Red
Jay Cutler

2006 Topps Turkey Red #190 Red Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
1 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Bowman Chrome #222 Blue Refractor
Jay Cutler

2006 Bowman Chrome #222 Blue Refractor Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
1 sales · BGS9.5 · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Topps Turkey Red #190 Gold
Jay Cutler

2006 Topps Turkey Red #190 Gold Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
1 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Score Hot Rookie #3 Base
Jay Cutler

2006 Score Hot Rookie #3 Base Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
1 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Bowman Chrome #222 Autograph
Jay Cutler

2006 Bowman Chrome #222 Autograph Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
1 sales · PSA10 · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Topps Triple Threads #108 Relic Autograph-Sepia
Jay Cutler

2006 Topps Triple Threads #108 Relic Autograph-Sepia Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
1 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Leaf Certified Materials #200 Mirror Blue
Jay Cutler

2006 Leaf Certified Materials #200 Mirror Blue Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
1 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Topps Signature Series #TAJC Base
Jay Cutler

2006 Topps Signature Series #TAJC Base Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
1 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Topps Draft Picks & Prospects #173 Base
Jay Cutler

2006 Topps Draft Picks & Prospects #173 Base Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
1 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Press Pass Se #6 Base
Jay Cutler

2006 Press Pass Se #6 Base Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
1 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler SP Authentic #226 Autograph
Jay Cutler

2006 SP Authentic #226 Autograph Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
1 sales · PSA10 · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Bowman #114 Gold
Jay Cutler

2006 Bowman #114 Gold Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
1 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Topps Draft Picks & Prospects Senior Standout-Jersey #SSJC Senior Standout-Jersey
Jay Cutler

2006 Topps Draft Picks & Prospects Senior Standout-Jersey #SSJC Senior Standout-Jersey Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
1 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler SA-GE Autographs #A14 Silver
Jay Cutler

2006 SA-GE Autographs #A14 Silver Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
1 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Jay Cutler Bowman Chrome #222 Gold Refractor
Jay Cutler

2006 Bowman Chrome #222 Gold Refractor Jay Cutler

0%
30 days
1 sales · RAW · 0% (30d)
Track Full Price History & Manage Your Collection

Complete sales history, collection tracking, and market alerts

Recent Jay Cutler Sales

The most recent completed Jay Cutler card sales from real eBay data.

DateCardGradePrice
2026-08-112006 SA-GE Autographs #A14 RedRaw$12
2026-08-112006 Press Pass Legends Autographs BaseRaw$17
2026-08-112006 Topps Turkey Red #190 BaseBGS9$10
2026-08-112006 Topps Turkey Red #190 BlackBGS9$16
2026-08-112006 Topps Draft Picks & Prospects #173 ChromePSA10$45
2026-08-102006 Leaf Certified Materials #200 Mirror Blue-AutographPSA8$45
2026-08-102006 Score #350 BasePSA10$15
2026-08-102006 Topps EA Sports Madden 07 #11 BasePSA10$24
2026-08-102006 Bowman #114 BaseRaw$2
2026-08-092006 Bowman Chrome #222 Gold Refractor AutographPSA9$255

Jay Cutler Rookie Sets

2006 Bowman Chrome (16)
2006 Topps Chrome (10)
2006 Score (9)
2006 Leaf Certified Materials (8)
2006 Playoff NFL Playoffs (8)
2006 Leaf Rookies & Stars Longevity (7)
2006 Bowman (6)
2006 Donruss Elite (6)
2006 Donruss Gridiron Gear (6)
2006 Leaf Limited (6)
2006 Playoff Absolute Memorabilia (5)
2006 Press Pass Certified Autograph (5)
2006 Topps Turkey Red (5)
2006 Ultra (5)
2006 Donruss Classics (4)
2006 Finest (4)
2006 Leaf Rookies & Stars Longevity Target (4)
2006 Playoff Contenders (4)
2006 Playoff National Treasures (4)
2006 Playoff Prestige Draft Picks (4)
2006 SA-GE Autographs (4)
2006 SA-GE Hit Design for Success (4)
2006 Score Hot Rookie (4)
2006 Score Select (4)
2006 Score Select Hot Rookies (4)
2006 Topps Draft Picks & Prospects (4)
2006 Leaf Rookies & Stars (3)
2006 Playoff Contenders R.O.Y. Contender (3)
2006 Playoff Prestige (3)
2006 Press Pass Legends (3)
2006 SA-GE Game Exclusives Autograph (3)
2006 Spx (3)
2006 Topps (3)
2006 Topps Draft Picks & Prospects Class Marks (3)
2006 Topps Heritage Chrome (3)
2006 Topps NFL 8306 (3)
2006 Topps Total (3)
2006 Topps Triple Threads (3)
2006 Upper Deck (3)
2006 Donruss Threads (2)
2006 Flair Showcase (2)
2006 Leaf Rookies & Stars 1948 Leaf Blue (2)
2006 Playoff Prestige Xtra Points (2)
2006 Press Pass (2)
2006 Press Pass Legends Legends Autographs (2)
2006 Press Pass Paydirt (2)
2006 Press Pass Se (2)
2006 SA-GE Aspire (2)
2006 SP Authentic Chirography Signatures (2)
2006 Topps Draft Picks & Prospects Senior Standout-Jersey (2)

Jay Cutler Rookie Set Breakdown

2006 Bowman Chrome

5 cards tracked · 8 sales in the last 30 days · Top grade: Raw (0%)

2006 Topps Chrome

1 card tracked · 2 sales in the last 30 days · Top grade: BGS9.5 (0%)

2006 Score

1 card tracked · 7 sales in the last 30 days · Top grade: Raw (0%)

2006 Leaf Certified Materials

1 card tracked · 1 sales in the last 30 days · Top grade: Raw (0%)

2006 Leaf Rookies & Stars Longevity

1 card tracked · 2 sales in the last 30 days · Top grade: Raw (0%)

2006 Bowman

1 card tracked · 1 sales in the last 30 days · Top grade: Raw (0%)

Frequently Asked Questions

How much is a Jay Cutler card worth?

The average price of a Jay Cutler graded card over the last 30 days is $22 across 59 sales.

Are Jay Cutler rookie cards going up or down?

Over the last 30 days, Jay Cutler cards have decreased by 0%.

What are the most popular Jay Cutler rookie card sets?

The most traded Jay Cutler rookie sets include Bowman Chrome, Topps Chrome, Score.

What is the best Jay Cutler rookie card to buy?

The most actively traded Jay Cutler rookie card is the 2006 Score #350, which gives it the deepest liquidity and the easiest resale. Base rookies from popular sets like Bowman Chrome and Topps Chrome are the most common starting points for collectors.

How many Jay Cutler cards sell per month?

59 Jay Cutler graded cards sold in the last 30 days with a total volume of $1,320.

Which Jay Cutler card has sold for the highest price?

The highest recorded sale in our last 30 days of data reached $255. The most actively traded Jay Cutler card is the 2006 Score #350 Base.

What is the most traded Jay Cutler card?

The 2006 Score #350 Base Jay Cutler card leads trading volume over the last 30 days.

What grade has the most Jay Cutler sales?

Raw leads the grade distribution with 45 sales in the last 30 days across all tracked Jay Cutler cards.

How has the Jay Cutler market performed over 30 days?

Jay Cutler cards have lost 0% in average value over the last 30 days across tracked sales.

Should I invest in Jay Cutler cards?

Card values depend on many factors including player performance, grade condition, and overall market conditions. Jay Cutler's 30-day data shows 59 sales averaging $22 with a negative trend of 0%. All card investments carry risk — consult the full price history before making decisions.

Which Jay Cutler parallel is most valuable?

Among tracked parallels, the 2006 Ultimate Collection #203 Autograph has led 30-day performance with a 0% change.

What year is the Jay Cutler rookie card from?

Jay Cutler's rookie cards are from 2006.

How do I verify Jay Cutler card prices?

SlabHawk tracks real eBay sales data for all graded Jay Cutler cards, updated daily. Every price shown is from an actual completed sale — not an asking price or estimate.

Collecting Guides

How to Check Card Values

Learn how to find what your football cards are worth across PSA, SGC, and BGS grades.

PSA vs SGC vs BGS

Compare the three biggest grading companies on cost, turnaround time, and resale value.

Best Cards to Invest In 2026

Data-driven picks for the NFL rookie cards with the best investment potential this year.

Prizm vs Donruss Optic

Which set is worth more? Compare value, parallels, and box prices with real market data.